Blog · Web development
Stripe, Mangopay or Lemonway: which payments for a marketplace

On this page
Pricing read on 16 November 2026, the three regulatory statuses, the hidden cost of seller KYC, and the five questions that actually decide.
For a marketplace, choosing a payment provider is not decided by the commission rate. It is decided by three questions: who holds the licence that lets you collect other people’s money, who handles identity verification for your sellers, and who carries the risk if a seller turns out to be fraudulent.
On those three points, Stripe, Mangopay and Lemonway do not give the same answer, and only one of the three publishes its pricing. Here is what we found on 16 November 2026, and how we decide on our own projects.
The starting point is legal, not commercial
When your platform collects the buyer’s payment before paying the seller, you are handling a third party’s money. Under French law, providing payment services is in principle reserved to licensed players, and article L. 521-3 of the French monetary and financial code sets out the exceptions to that prohibition.
Those exceptions are narrow. They cover payment instruments accepted only on the company’s premises or, under a commercial agreement with it, within a limited network of people, or for a limited range of goods or services. In other words closed loops, retailer gift cards, meal vouchers. Not an open marketplace.
The same article sets a threshold few founders know about: as soon as the total value of payment transactions executed over the previous twelve months exceeds one million euros, the company must file a declaration with the French prudential supervisor, stating which exclusion it operates under, and update it every year. If the supervisor notifies that the conditions are not met, the company has three months to comply or apply for authorisation.
Practical conclusion: barring very particular cases, you do not hold that licence, and your provider holds it for you. That is the real service you are buying. The commission is merely its advertised price.
Three statuses, three different promises
This is the first filter, and it can be checked in thirty seconds on the providers’ own sites.
- Lemonway presents itself as a payment institution authorised by the French prudential supervisor under number 16568, since 2012. French licence, French authority, French counterpart. Source: their site.
- Mangopay presents itself as an electronic money institution licensed in the European Economic Area, operating since 2013, and points to the European register of payment institutions. Source: their pricing page.
- Stripe names no supervisory authority on its pricing pages. You read that it complies with industry standards and holds licences worldwide, with no country or number specified.
The difference between a payment institution and an electronic money institution is not cosmetic. The latter can hold value in wallets in your users’ names, which allows escrow and deferred payout scenarios. The former executes and routes transactions. If your model involves holding funds pending delivery or approval, the question arises during scoping. We recommend having it settled by legal counsel, not by a product page.
What Stripe publishes, line by line
Stripe is the only one of the three to display a full grid, and that is a real advantage: you can model your cost before signing. Taken from their French pricing page, card acquiring costs 1.5% plus 0.25 euros for a standard European card, 2.8% plus 0.25 euros for a premium European card, 2.5% plus 0.25 euros for a UK card and 3.15% plus 0.25 euros for other international cards. A currency conversion adds 2%.
The marketplace part sits on the Connect pricing page, and it offers two models that must be told apart. In the first, Stripe manages the pricing applied to your sellers, and the platform pays nothing on accounts or payouts. In the second, you manage that pricing, and you then pay 2 euros per active connected account per month, an account counting as active in any month where payouts go to its bank account or card.
In that second model, add 0.25% plus 0.10 euros per payout to a seller, 1% for an instant payout, and 1.4% on account debits. Risk-based know-your-customer checks are listed as included.
So the calculation to run is the following, and it is counter-intuitive: on a marketplace with many small sellers receiving little, the 2 euros per active account per month can weigh more than the transaction commission. We covered how this works in our article on Stripe Connect for a marketplace.
What the other two do not publish, and why
Mangopay explicitly states a custom, volume-based pricing model, with no public tiers and no free plan, pricing being agreed by contract. Lemonway displays no pricing at all and points to a contact form.
Read that without naivety, in both directions. The upside is real: a negotiated grid fits your model, your average basket and your payment mix, and the price falls as volume grows. The downside is just as real: you cannot model your cost before entering a sales conversation, nor compare three offers in an hour. For a young marketplace still validating its economics, that opacity is a cost in itself.
Our practice: always ask for a priced grid against three volume scenarios, today’s, twelve months out and thirty-six months out. A provider who refuses to project the volume discount tells you something about the rest of the relationship.
The item everyone forgets: seller KYC
This is by far the main source of friction in production, well ahead of the commission. Every professional seller has to be identified, their company verified, their beneficial owners documented, and those checks kept up to date. A blocked seller is a seller who does not get their money, calls your support, and speaks badly of you.
Three things to look at before choosing. The geographic coverage of the verification, because a provider that handles France well can be laborious on Eastern Europe or Africa. The average validation time for a professional seller, to be asked in working days and confirmed in writing. And the onboarding experience, meaning whether the seller stays on your site or is sent to a third-party page, which weighs directly on your drop-off rate.
Stripe bills its identity verification product separately from Connect, where the basic checks are included. The other two fold verification into their offer, under contract-dependent conditions. We described the pitfalls of this part in our article on KYC and anti-money laundering on a marketplace.
How we decide, in five questions
They come in this order, and the first decisive answer is often enough.
Do you need to hold funds pending something, for escrow, a delivery to confirm or a dispute? If so, look for an institution able to hold wallets, and get that confirmed in writing. Are your sellers French, European or global? Verification coverage then becomes the number one criterion.
Is your volume already significant? Below a few hundred thousand euros a year, Stripe’s public grid is almost always better value than a negotiated contract, and above all it is available immediately. Do you have many small sellers? Then redo the cost-per-active-account calculation, which changes the ranking. Finally, is a French licence required by your clients or your sector? In banking, insurance or the public sector the answer is sometimes yes, and it settles the debate on its own.
The three traps we see most
The first is the segregation of funds. None of the three providers highlights this notion on its public pages, yet it is exactly what determines what happens to your sellers’ money if your company or your provider runs into trouble. To be spelled out in the contract, not assumed.
The second is reversibility. Changing payment provider is not a matter of swapping an API key: you have to put all your sellers through identity verification again, convince them to start over, and manage the period where both systems coexist. That is the real exit cost, and it grows with your number of sellers. Better to know it going in.
The third is the reporting obligation that falls on you, not on your provider. As a platform operator, you report your sellers’ earnings to the tax authorities every year, under articles 1649 ter A to 1649 ter E of the French general tax code, with a 31 January deadline for the previous year. It is not optional and it is prepared in your data model, not in January.
What we take away from it
All three providers do the job. Stripe wins on pricing transparency, tooling quality and speed to start, and it is our default choice, as we explained in our article on our payment solution. Lemonway leads with a French licence, which matters in regulated sectors and with certain public buyers. Mangopay leads with electronic money institution status and wallets, useful for models involving escrow.
But the ranking depends on your flow of funds, not on the rate card. Two marketplaces with the same revenue can face radically different bills and constraints depending on the number of sellers, their countries and the moment the money changes hands.
We scope and build these platforms, from modelling the flow of funds to wiring up the provider. If you are hesitating between two solutions for a specific project, our marketplace page sets out how we work, and you can talk it through with us.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Does a marketplace need a license to collect payments?
Collecting third-party money falls under payment services, which are in principle reserved for licensed entities. Article L. 521-3 of the French Monetary and Financial Code provides for narrow exclusions, limited to payment methods accepted on the company's premises, within a limited network of persons, or for a limited range of goods and services. Beyond one million euros in transactions over the previous twelve months, a declaration to the ACPR is mandatory. In practice, most marketplaces rely on their provider's license.
How much does Stripe Connect cost for a marketplace?
As of November 16, 2026, collecting with a standard European card costs 1.5% plus 0.25 euro, and 3.15% plus 0.25 euro for an international card outside the UK. On Connect, two models exist: if Stripe manages your sellers' pricing, the platform pays nothing on accounts and transfers; if you manage it, count 2 euros per active connected account per month, plus 0.25% and 0.10 euro per transfer, and 1% for an instant transfer.
Do Mangopay and Lemonway publish their pricing?
No. Mangopay indicates a custom model based on volume, with no public tiers or free offer, pricing being set by contract. Lemonway displays no pricing and refers to a contact form. The advantage is a rate card tailored to your model; the drawback is the inability to simulate your cost before entering commercial discussions.
What is the difference between a payment institution and an electronic money institution?
An electronic money institution can hold value in wallets in your users' names, which allows for escrow and deferred payout. A payment institution executes and routes transactions. Lemonway presents itself as a payment institution licensed by the ACPR under number 16568, Mangopay as an electronic money institution licensed in the European Economic Area. If your model involves holding funds, have a lawyer settle the question during scoping.
What is the real cost of switching payment providers?
Seller identity verification. Switching providers requires re-running KYC for all your sellers, convincing them to start over, and managing the coexistence of both systems. This cost grows with the number of sellers, making it an initial selection criterion rather than an end-of-contract issue.
Read next
Guides on the same topic
Explore the topic further with a selection of complementary resources.